News & Insights

What Happens If You Miss the Deadline for Taking an Elective Share?

In New York, you cannot disinherit your spouse unless your spouse waived the right to inherit in a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement. If you improperly exclude your spouse from your will, he or she can exercise the right to an elective share of your estate. However, this elective share is not automatic. Strict time limits apply, with little recourse if the deadline is missed, which is why surviving spouses must act quickly to make a decision.

If the election is filed, the surviving spouse is entitled to receive the greater of $50,000 or one-third of the net value of the “augmented estate” after expenses. This includes not only assets that pass through the estate, but also non-testamentary assets, such as:

  • Amounts in excess of the annual exclusion amount ($19,000 in 2026) gifted in the year prior to death
  • Other gifts “causa mortis” or made in contemplation of death
  • Joint and Totten trust accounts
  • Transfers of property to be held as joint tenant with the right of survivorship or with a reserved life estate
  • Assets placed in a trust where the deceased spouse retained income rights
  • Retirement account assets (401(k)/IRA)
  • Property over which the decedent spouse had a general power of appointment.

One thing the augmented estate does not include is life insurance.

In order to receive the elective share, a spouse must serve a written election on the estate representative within 6 months after the appointment of the representative or two years after the date of death, whichever comes first.

But what happens when this deadline is missed? This issue was addressed by the New York Appellate Division, First Department in Matter of Giurdanella.

The appellant was an 88-year-old widow whose husband died in December 2021 with an estate worth more than $45 million. One year prior to his death, the husband transferred his estate assets into a revocable trust, which provided his wife with an income interest, but no right to principal distributions. Those distributions were permitted only in the discretion of the Trustee.

The widow developed medical problems shortly after her husband’s death. An attorney who had long represented the family prepared a power of attorney, which named one of the widow’s children as attorney-in-fact (that child was the respondent in the case). The same attorney also prepared a waiver and consent to the probate of the husband’s estate, and estate planning documents for the widow, but did not provide drafts or explain their significance. Further, the attorney never discussed the elective share with the widow during the 6-month period when she had an absolute right to exercise the right and never told her the value of the estate.

The widow never obtained a copy of her husband’s revocable trust until March 2023. Shortly thereafter, the attorney formally terminated his representation of the widow without explanation, but continued to represent the respondent child/attorney-in-fact.

In September 2024, the widow retained new counsel and filed a notice of election of the elective share. The respondent contested it on the grounds that the deadline to elect had expired, and the Surrogate granted the motion to dismiss.

While the elective share statute grants the court the authority to extend the time to exercise the elective share beyond 6 months, it is expressly prohibited to permit the exercise more than 12 months after an executor is appointed. Therefore, the appellate court affirmed the Surrogate’s decision, finding that the elective share filing was too late. However, the widow could pursue her claim under the doctrine of equitable estoppel.

Equitable estoppel is a legal principle that prevents a party from benefiting from its own improper conduct to defeat a claim. The court found that, due in part to the egregious circumstances and conduct of the attorney, who had represented both the widow and the respondent, the respondent should be prevented from objecting to the election based on the fact that it was past the deadline.

The court noted that where a fiduciary “fails to disclose material information necessary to exercise protected rights,” courts are particularly open to equitable estoppel arguments.

The court found that the widow had successfully pleaded facts which met the elements of equitable estoppel: (1) misconduct that caused the delay; (2) reasonable reliance; (3) a causal connection between the misconduct and the delay; and (4) due diligence once the impediment ceased. Accordingly, the widow’s case could proceed because it would be unfair to allow the respondent to benefit from withholding information.

While the facts supporting the equitable estoppel argument are fairly unique, the broader takeaway is that the court has strict limits on its ability to extend the time to exercise the elective share. As a result, it is important that after the death of a spouse, the surviving spouse consult legal counsel, particularly where the survivor is not the executor of the decedent’s estate.

If you have questions about probate or administration of an estate, contact our firm to discuss your situation.